Specialist Social Work

Testamentary Mental Capacity Assessments

Independent Testamentary Capacity Assessments for Wills and Estate Planning

Do you require a Testamentary Mental Capacity Assessment to support the creation, amendment, or validation of a will?

At Specialist Social Work, we provide professional and independent Testamentary Capacity Assessments for solicitors, will writers, private clients, families, deputies, and Court of Protection professionals. Our assessments help determine whether an individual has the legal capacity to make, amend, or revoke a will and provide robust evidence that can withstand future scrutiny or challenge.

Our experienced Social Workers and Best Interests Assessors have completed thousands of Mental Capacity Assessments since 2009 and regularly provide reports in complex legal, probate, and Court of Protection matters.

What Is Testamentary Capacity?

Testamentary capacity is the legal ability to make or amend a valid will.

When preparing a will, solicitors and will writers must be satisfied that the person making the will (the testator) understands the nature and consequences of their decisions. Where there are concerns about age, illness, cognitive impairment, dementia, or vulnerability, obtaining an independent Testamentary Mental Capacity Assessment is often considered best practice.

A professionally completed assessment can:

  • Support the validity of a new will
  • Assist solicitors in meeting professional obligations
  • Reduce the risk of future disputes
  • Provide contemporaneous evidence of capacity
  • Help defend the will against challenges after death

Why Is Testamentary Capacity Important?

Disputes over wills are often centred on whether the testator understood the decisions they were making at the time the will was executed.

A contemporaneous Testamentary Capacity Assessment provides independent evidence that the individual:

  • Understood they were making a will
  • Understood the effect of the will
  • Understood their assets and estate
  • Considered those who may reasonably expect to benefit
  • Made decisions free from impairment or undue influence

This evidence can be invaluable where there are concerns about dementia, memory loss, cognitive impairment, mental illness, or family disputes.

The Golden Rule and Testamentary Capacity

Solicitors are often guided by what is commonly referred to as the Golden Rule when preparing wills for elderly or seriously ill clients.

The Golden Rule recommends obtaining a professional assessment of capacity and keeping a contemporaneous record of the assessment findings. This additional safeguard can help demonstrate that the testator understood the will and had the necessary capacity at the time it was made.

Our assessments help solicitors and will writers satisfy this important professional safeguard and provide reliable evidence should the will later be contested.

How Is Testamentary Capacity Assessed?

The Banks v Goodfellow Test

Unlike many Mental Capacity Assessments, testamentary capacity is not determined using the standard decision-making test contained within the Mental Capacity Act 2005.

Instead, testamentary capacity is assessed using the long-established common law principles derived from Banks v Goodfellow, the leading legal authority governing capacity to make a will.

To have testamentary capacity, the testator must be able to:

Understand the Nature and Effect of Making a Will

The individual must understand that they are making a will and appreciate its legal consequences.

Understand the Extent of Their Estate

They should have a reasonable understanding of the assets, property, finances, and possessions being distributed.

Consider Potential Beneficiaries

They must be able to understand and appreciate the claims of those who might reasonably expect to benefit from their estate.

Be Free From Delusions Affecting the Will

The individual must not be influenced by a delusion, disorder, or false belief that affects the distribution of their estate.

Why Choose Specialist Social Work?

Our family-run team of assessors understand the legal, evidential, and practical requirements associated with testamentary capacity assessments.

We offer:

  • Testamentary Capacity Assessments
  • Capacity to Make a Will Assessments
  • Probate and Estate Planning Reports
  • Court of Protection Reports
  • Statutory Will Capacity Assessments
  • Expert Witness Services
  • Solicitor Support Services

Our reports are evidence-based, professionally reasoned, and designed to withstand legal scrutiny in probate disputes and contested will proceedings.

Our Testamentary Capacity Assessment Process

Professional, Thorough and Person-Centred

Our assessment process is designed to be efficient while ensuring a comprehensive evaluation of testamentary capacity.

Initial Instruction

Following instruction, we gather key information regarding the proposed will and the reasons for the assessment.

Review of the Draft Will

Where available, we request a copy of the draft will to assist with assessment planning and question development.

Assessment Interview

The assessment typically takes between one and two hours and explores the individual's understanding of:

  • Their will
  • Their assets
  • Their beneficiaries
  • Their reasons for making particular decisions

Independent Evaluation

Whilst family members or supporters may be present for part of the visit where appropriate, we generally seek an opportunity to spend time alone with the individual to ensure independence and minimise the potential for external influence.

Comprehensive Written Report

Following assessment, we prepare a detailed report outlining:

  • The legal test applied
  • The information considered
  • Assessment findings
  • Capacity analysis
  • Professional conclusions

Assessment Timescales

We understand that will preparation and estate planning matters can be time-sensitive.

We aim to complete Testamentary Capacity Assessments and reports within 21 days of instruction, although urgent assessments can often be accommodated where necessary.

What Happens If Someone Lacks Testamentary Capacity?

If the assessment concludes that the individual lacks testamentary capacity, they may be unable to create or amend a valid will.

In some circumstances, it may be appropriate to apply to the Court of Protection for a Statutory Will, allowing the Court to approve a will on behalf of a person who lacks capacity.

Our assessment reports can provide important evidence to support such applications and assist legal professionals in determining the most appropriate next steps.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is testamentary capacity?

Testamentary capacity is the legal ability to make, amend, or revoke a valid will.

Who should have a Testamentary Capacity Assessment?

An assessment may be beneficial where a person:

  • Has dementia
  • Has memory difficulties
  • Has suffered a brain injury
  • Has a mental health condition
  • Is seriously ill
  • Is making significant changes to a will
  • May be vulnerable to challenge or dispute
What is the Golden Rule for wills?

The Golden Rule encourages solicitors to obtain a professional assessment of capacity when preparing a will for an elderly or seriously ill person and to retain a record of that assessment.

Is testamentary capacity assessed under the Mental Capacity Act?

Not usually. Testamentary capacity is generally assessed using the common law principles established in Banks v Goodfellow rather than the standard Mental Capacity Act test.

How long does a Testamentary Capacity Assessment take?

Most assessments last between one and two hours, with reports typically completed within 21 days of instruction.

Can solicitors instruct you directly?

Yes. We regularly receive instructions from solicitors, private client departments, will writers, Court of Protection teams, deputies, and private individuals.

Can your reports be used in court?

Yes. Our reports are designed to support estate planning, probate matters, contested wills, Court of Protection applications, and other legal proceedings.

What is a Statutory Will?

A Statutory Will is a will approved by the Court of Protection on behalf of a person who lacks testamentary capacity.

Contact Us

If you require a Testamentary Mental Capacity Assessment, Capacity to Make a Will Assessment, Statutory Will Report, or Expert Witness Opinion, our experienced team can help.

Contact Specialist Social Work today to arrange an independent Testamentary Capacity Assessment and obtain professionally prepared evidence for will drafting, estate planning, or probate matters.

Contact us